|
Brandeis Issues 'Ridiculous' Commandments for Heston Speech
Eric Langborgh
bomb-sniffing dog, two full-body metal detectors, two hand-held metal detector
wands, at least ten security guards, and four units of the guest's blood type
are all that Brandeis University's administration is requiring of student
organizers to keep the March 28 Charlton Heston speech from being canceled.
Citing the president of the
National Rifle Association's "controversial views" as the reason
behind their actions, Brandeis University proceeded to require the series of
security requirements that Heston's publicists and seasoned security personnel
have labeled "ridiculous," and have made the group of students
bringing the famous actor to campus wonder if the administration is accepting a
form of the heckler's veto of the event.
"Once we leap one hurdle, we
have to leap another," Bryan Rudnick, editor of the event's sponsor, Freedom
Magazine, explained.
Those hurdles are not cheap.
Estimates place rental of the dog at $1000, the ten to fifteen police officers
from Brandeis'
Office of Public Safety and the Town of
Waltham, Massachusetts Police Department at $2500, and the two full-body metal
detectors to be placed at the auditorium entrance doors at $2500.
The administration, though,
vehemently denies an attempt at censorship of Heston's conservative views and
disputes the claim that they requested his blood type.
"We are not putting
roadblocks in this kid's way," protested Vice-President of Public Affairs
Michal Reagunberg. "If he wants to lie about it, that's fine, but I don't
have to play his game."
Yet Rudnick holds that Ed
Callahan, the Director of Public Safety at Brandeis, did in fact state that they
would require Heston's blood type along with the paramedic team the school says
it usually keeps ready for large public events. According to Rudnick, Callahan
made this demand during a meeting on March 8 in his office with Stephanie Ruark
from the Office of Campus Life, Roman Cermak from the Office of Conferences and
Events, and Reagunberg all present.
All involved, however, refused to
answer direct questions from Campus Report,
instead referring all inquiries to Dennis Nealon, the Director of Media
Relations, who did not attend the meeting but nonetheless has taken the role of
"official" voice for Brandeis University.
Nealon claimed he made no
directive for a media blackout by employees of the University, despite the
unwillingness of those interviewed to answer direct questions surrounding the
March 8 meeting on the blood charge and the school's reasoning behind the heavy
security requirements. "I frankly don't give a damn what you write,"
swore Nealon in response to a question regarding this.
"That's why we have media
relations here," offered Cermak in defense of his refusal to answer
questions. Still, when pressed about the March 8 meeting, Cermak retorted,
"How do you know I was at that meeting?" though he neither confirmed
nor denied his presence there.
Callahan, too, swore silence when
questioned, deferring all inquiries to the "official spokesman" for
the University, Dennis Nealon. Callahan, however, would neither confirm nor deny
that he requested Heston's blood type.
Nealon, for his part, terms the
claim "nonsense," saying, "[Rudnick] is the only one with that
impression on the whole campus."
A spokesman at Waltham Deaconess
Hospital said that he was not aware of any contact with the University regarding
blood supplies, and Heston's publicist has also not been contacted by the
University regarding Heston's blood type, leading some to surmise that officials
at the school chose to drop the demand soon after it was announced.
Regardless, the other security
precautions are not in dispute. What is in dispute, though, is whether they are
the "standard security measures" Nealon contends "would be
adopted in the event of anyone of [Heston's] stature."
"First of all, they are not
extreme," Nealon told Campus Report.
"They are the cautions the University deems appropriate to ensure as best
it can the safety of a very prominent figure who is an international celebrity,
as well as a representative of some very controversial views."
It is this sentiment that has
Rudnick worried the Brandeis Administration is trying to silence his group and
force the cancellation of Heston's speech. "Instead of saying his ideas
spark controversy, they say Heston has 'controversial views,'"
Rudnick pointed out. "Who is the arbiter
of what's controversial and what's not?"
Nealon stated that this is not
the first time similar security precautions have been instituted on
student-sponsored events at least partially at student expense. However, despite
claiming they have been used a "few times" in the past, he could only
name one: Meir Kahane.
Students invited Rabbi Meir
Kahane, the radical founder of the militant Jewish Defense League, to the campus
in the late eighties. Unlike Heston, though, Kahane came amid very public
threats of assassination against him by Muslim fanatics. In fact, Kahane was
assassinated shortly after his speech at Brandeis by Arab terrorist El Sayyid
Nosair, known now for his involvement in the bombing of the World Trade Center
in New York City.
In the case of Charlton Heston,
on the other hand, the school has received no death threats and none have been
publicly made against him.
What they do point to is a
protest Heston witnessed when he recently traveled to Northwestern University—the
school he attended more than four decades ago. The extent of the distraction:
two students were escorted away from Heston's speech for refusing to put down
their placards inside the auditorium. The two students were cited—not
arrested, as Nealon claimed—for disorderly conduct after ignoring repeated
warnings to lower their signs so they would not be a distraction to other
audience members' ability to see the event. Security at Northwestern and at
recent Heston events at Pennsylvania State University, the University of
Colorado at Boulder, and American University have consisted of, on average, two
security personnel inside and two outside the respective auditoriums. Only
common sense guidelines like prohibitions on bringing backpacks into the event
were issued. In the case of Penn State, over 2500 people attended Heston's
speech with no incidents reported, even though bomb-sniffing dogs and metal
detectors were not present.
"They do security
different" than we do, answered Nealon when asked about this.
Nealon also claims that Rudnick's
group has greatly exaggerated the cost imposed upon them, saying the cost is
"more like $3500."
"That's because he can't
do simple math," Rudnick retorted, pointing to a sum total of at least
$6000, and possibly much more when the additional cost of chairs, placed upon
them when they were forced to change locales for the speech, and even more so
for the two hand-held metal detector wands mandated by the University.
"If there is a political
agenda at work here, it has nothing to do with the University," Nealon
asserted, adding that Brandeis has picked up some of the direct costs for the
event through certain departments like the Office of Public Safety, though
Rudnick says he'll believe it when he sees it, and that these concession have
followed media pressure. Dean of Student Affairs Rod Crafts has also relented
and agreed to pay for one of the metal detectors. In addition, the student
government has chipped in $5000, though that money comes not from tuition or the
administration, but from the mandatory student activities fee.
This is not the first time that
Rudnick has had run-ins with the Brandeis Administration. Last school year, the
administration looked the other way after hundreds of issues of his publication,
Freedom Magazine, were trashed on separate occasions by objecting student
senators. The lack of condemnation by the administration of the destruction of
property and the censorship of conservative views was seen by many as tacit
approval of the vandals' actions. The same student senators later lead the
charge to de-fund and de-charter the conservative student publication.
Over the course of Rudnick's four
years at Brandeis, conservative speakers have been almost non-existent. Only
conservative lawyer and columnist Ann Coulter, grassroots organizer for the NRA
Glen Caroline, and author Dinesh D'Souza have been brought to campus to speak,
and then only due to the efforts of Rudnick. Meanwhile, liberal activists, like
former White House spokesman George Stephanopoulis and feminist Gloria Steinem,
have regularly appeared on campus, with Robert Reich, Anita Hill, Ann Richards,
and Ed Koch all taking at least temporary spots on the Brandeis faculty. Hill
just had her contract renewed for three more years.
As for the Heston event, the
speech is scheduled to proceed as scheduled, but the whole fiasco surrounding
security at the event has left a sour taste in many mouths.
|