|
Penn State Feminists Stage X-Rated Event on Students' Dime
Eric
Langborgh
Feminists at Pennsylvania
State University shocked the campus on the evening of November 18 by staging an
explicit event featuring nudity, vulgar sexual references, and anti-male rants.
Students in charge of allocating University monies to student groups maintain
that they were deceived into thinking "CuntFest," the program named
after a feminist manifesto, would focus on the book and not expand into
promotion of radical lesbianism and pornographic art.
While campus security
did nothing to stop the strip-show, they did order this reporter on several
occasions to stop covering the event.
Militant student
feminists convinced members of the University Park Allocation Committee (UPAC)
to fund the program despite concerns over the title. An investigation has begun
and may result in sanctions against the offending groups which brought the
conference to campus.
"Wow!"
exclaimed UPAC chairman Eddie Elizondo following a description to him of the
graphic nature of the forum titled after Inga Muscio's book Cunt: A
Declaration of Independence. "That is not at all what was conveyed to
us about what would be happening at that event," he said.
What
happened at the event included a lesbian performance artist whose nude and
semi-nude skits went way beyond the description given to UPAC for approval—an
approval which netted Womyn's Concerns and the Feminist Majority Leadership
Alliance (FMLA) nearly $10,000 of student activity fee funds to pay the
honoraria and travel/lodging costs of CuntFest's seven performers and
presenters.
Campus
Report attended the event, much to
the dismay of conference organizers. When asked beforehand whether the
controversially titled event would include explicit or pornographic material,
CuntFest's Penn State co-director Missy Mazzaferro answered in the negative.
This suggested that the event might have been misrepresented to UPAC, as well.
Forms
obtained from UPAC show that Womyn's Concerns and the FMLA were hardly vague
in their description of what would be happening at CuntFest. "The evening
will feature woman-centered, cuntlovin' fun entertainment," read the
program description included with the budget request. "Inga Muscio will
read excerpts from her book Cunt. Performance artist Jess Dobkin will
present a series of short pieces." The description went on to mention
musical entertainment and poetry, as well as a series of
"self-protection" workshops earlier in the day, but failed to mention
the graphic nudity of Dobkin's act.
Nevertheless,
Elizondo claimed, "We had no indication that anything of that nature would
be taking place. I believe they definitely did [misrepresent the event], based
on what you just told me," he replied. Elizondo noted that though UPAC is
an "allocating, not a policing body" and therefore could not directly
discipline the student groups involved, an investigation would be launched
through appropriate student disciplinary bodies with sanctions as a possible
result, and perhaps even a freezing of their accounts, thus prohibiting them
from organizing future events.
Critics,
however, wonder how the University could have expected anything else from an
event with such a name, and suggest funding never should have been appropriated
in the first place.
Warning: X-Rated
Despite
being assured in a phone call before heading to Penn State and in an interview
preceding the start of CuntFest's evening programs that reporters were
welcome, Campus Report
was warned just prior to Dobkin's performance not to take notes of any kind.
Sensing a cover up, this reporter refused, pleading First Amendment rights to a
free press and free speech to the two police officers present who asked three
times for Campus Report
to cease and desist. When refused, the officers conceded "it's not a
matter of law" and allowed this reporter to continue taking notes. While
the controversial art piece was meant to titillate the audience, it contained
elements that critics considered disgusting and entirely inappropriate for a
college setting, which some suggest likely prompted conference organizers to
suppress media involvement.
Dobkin
began the performance by asking the audience to "participate" by
taking noisemakers out of a "pussy bag" made of papier-mâché. She
then handed out maxi-pad nose coverings she called "pussy sniffers."
"Now a friend of mine when I told her I was making 'pussy sniffers,'
she was pretty concerned," Dobkin shared with the audience. "She's
like, 'Jess, I don't think that's very sanitary,' you know, because I
was planning to wear them all first…. She seemed to think that maybe they
should come clean and you can put your pussy of choice on there and then it's
right up there where you need it anytime you need it."
Later,
it was noted that she had a cord hanging from her pink, fluffy dress with a
black tank top. Amid crude remarks, it was soon discovered that the cord was
attached to an electric pencil sharpener, in which she proceeded to sharpen a
series of pencils that she handed to audience members amid sexual utterances.
Innuendo
then took a back seat to nudity when she removed her top to reveal her breasts,
which she had painted to look like smiley faces with her nipples acting as
noses. Coupled with audible gasps from the crowd, she proceeded to suck each
breast; presumably to enable her to subsequently thread strings through her
pierced nipples. These strings were then used to maneuver her breasts like
puppets as she stood behind a prop made to look like a brick house with two
holes cut out for her breasts so they could "talk" to one another.
For
much of the rest of her performance she wore a black nightgown from which a
breast would often fall out.
From
a grab-bag of "tricks," Dobkin proceeded to extract numerous objects,
to which she attached sexual connotations. For instance, she discussed uses for
baby carrots ("don't snack on a carrot after it has been in your
ass") and brought out a "ruled" rubber glove (for giving one's
lesbian girlfriend "just the right amount").
Following
a graphic description of lesbian oral sex, she showed a film she had made on a
big screen television titled, Butt-F—ing Bunny. On screen were paper
puppets acting out crude sexual practices and then performing what is described
in the title on a paper rabbit puppet.
In
her final skit, Dobkin came out from behind a screen completely naked, except
for an apparatus that had swinging castle doors in the front. These eventually
opened to completely reveal herself as she performed a play on "The Emperor's
New Clothes" with the same paper puppets as before. Most tasteless to
critics was the red paint of some sort (likely finger paint) she had running
down her legs from her crotch area to represent menstruation. She then proceeded
to repeatedly take a paintbrush to her crotch and paint her belly and breasts.
When
asked about the graphic nature of the performance, Officer Frank Ball claimed
that "performance art is exempt from public exposure laws." He offered
no line that could be crossed—even sexual activity—"unless someone in
this room complained," Ball told Campus
Report.
Program Focused on 'Shock-Value'
Right
from the beginning, CuntFest was geared toward shocking the senses with both
visual and verbal imagery. Walking in the host building's door, potential
audience members and other students just going about their business were
unwittingly confronted with a four-foot tall ceramic model of a vagina.
Conference organizers would then offer what appeared to be fruit juice poured
from a spout just underneath the "clitoris" to passersby by asking,
"Would you like some 'pussy juice'?"
In
addition, many of the members of FMLA, Womyn's Concerns, and Alliance for
Animal Rights (a co-sponsor which hosted a "vegan dinner" for those
interested beforehand) were decked out with dyed, pointy hair and a plethora of
facial rings piercing their noses, mouths, tongues, and ears. Organizers also
sold red soap embroidered with the word "cunt."
"It's
obviously about shock-value," shared Penn State graduate student Jason
Covener, a member of the Penn State Young Americans for Freedom. "I think
it's an irresponsible use of that money. I think there's a lot better things
they can spend it on."
One
objection raised to CuntFest was that fees mandated from students to fund
various student groups and activities went to fund such an objectionable
program. The student activity fee at Penn State this year is $38 per semester,
or $76 per school year.
"The
whole idea of student activity money is it is supposed to improve student life,
improve campus life," explained Covener. "If you look at the content,
I really don't think the students got $10,000 worth of improvement in our
academic culture here." The official total was $9,519.64, of which $7,000
went toward honoraria.
Organizers
disagree. As one unnamed supporter said, "The University takes our money,
why can't we get some of it back for programs we want?"
The
co-directors for the event, Mazzaferro and Michelle Yates, explained to Campus
Report what their intended goal
was: "The word 'cunt' originally came from positive ancestral origins
and it is now one of the worst words you can call a woman," declared Yates,
who also serves as the president of FMLA. "The whole goal is for women to
reclaim the word 'cunt' back and transform the meaning of the word back to
something positive, like 'mother goddess.'"
Added
Mazzaferro, "The point in trying to reclaim the word 'cunt' is there is
no comparable word for a man. Cunt is a word that oppresses women; it holds
women down. If that word doesn't have the same negative connotations,"
she said, "she is not being oppressed—it even means something
positive."
Yet
when asked to define what she meant by oppression, and how words can hold
someone down, Mazzaferro objected to those who don't subscribe to her view
entering the dialogue. "I don't think you should be writing this article
if you are asking 'what do you think oppression is?' because right now you
are pretty much implying that women are not oppressed," she retorted.
Racism,
homophobia, pollution, and misogyny are all related, she declared. So who, then,
is the common enemy? "I don't want to name it that way, but it is the
white, heterosexual male."
'Filled with Hate'
This
view of an enemy that must be vanquished reared its head many times during the
program. Cristien Storm, the executive director of the Seattle-based Home Alive,
was among the most vocal in her rage. "I'm kind of just tired of all this
talk of 'reverse-isms, reverse-isms, reverse-isms…. Let's get together and
reverse this bigotry and hate," she proclaimed to the audience.
Later,
Inga Muscio asked Storm to sing one more song in order to presage her headlining
remarks. Shouted Storm:
"It's
too late,
'cause
now I'm filled with hate…
And
I hate you!
more
than you EVER, hated me…
And
I'll rape you!
more
than you EVER, loved me…."
In
particular, CuntFest's targets included the Republican Party (Yates decried
their convention as "those damn Republicans in Philadelphia" while
Dobkin spoke joyously about smashing piñata representations of New York City
mayor Rudolph Guiliani) and Accuracy in Academia, the publisher of Campus
Report.
Muscio
labeled AIA as "dangerous" and a "fringe group." "I
think their goal is … well, I'm not sure what their goal is, but I'm
pretty sure it is to silence me and other artists like Eve Ensler,"
hypothesized Muscio about herself and the author of the off-Broadway play, The
Vagina Monologues. "They present themselves as an organization that is
about objective truth, but what people claim and what the results from what
their activities are, are often two different things."
"Your
school is under attack by this group," she continued. "They want
students to not have access to funding unless it is something Accuracy in
Academia thinks is okay."
"Personally
that's scary, and to me that's scary as a human being. For you all, and for
other people going to school, I'm really scared. It scares me to think that
people would prefer to silence someone rather than just let everybody be, you
know?"
Men
in general incurred Muscio's wrath as she read to the audience excerpts from a
new book she is working on. The book's setting surrounds the exploits of a
woman who was gang-raped and then seeks her revenge by becoming a cunning serial
killer. "So she has indeed done this—killed a lot of people over a long
period of time," she read. "But the people she has killed are all the
fathers and sons from six families. I think she has left the women alone; that
is, aside from sundering their lives and killing their children."
She
continued: "'They shouldn't have mated with the beast,' she [the
killer] insists. 'I left them their daughters.'
"What
about the woman who has four sons and no daughters? What about her, huh?'….
"'It's
all relative, darling,' she sighs and looks deeply into my eyes…. 'It
really is all relative,'" she read from her upcoming book.
A
radical form of abortion was endorsed during Muscio's talk, as well as in her
book, Cunt: A Declaration of Independence. Specifically, she promoted a
"visualization" technique coupled with a concoction of herbs to
terminate unwanted pregnancies. Regarding a 17 year-old rape victim from
Virginia who had performed this abortion on herself, Muscio explained, "She
told me that it filled her with power to realize that she could have such a huge
effect on her own body and in her own life."
A Religious Experience
The
various themes that ran through CuntFest and the book for which the festival was
named seemed to be a religious awakening to the supporters present in the crowd
of over a hundred. The women on the stage were more explicit.
"It
is toward the ultimate end of feeling empowered," expressed Mazzaferro, who
concluded that women should be able to express their sexual desires in public,
to live out these desires, and to have control over their lives.
For
Yates, Cunt: A Declaration of Independence is her Bible. "If
something very shitty is going on in my life, I pick up that book and can find a
part of it to read to help me; even just practical things like 'hmm, what
birth control should I use?'"
Lesbianism
is the living out of this faith. "I dreamt of Medusa, of Cleopatra, of
Catherine riding bareback in the town square," divulged poet Dora McQuaid.
"I dreamt of women who held love like a power, wielded it like a tool, and
ruled ruthless and adamant."
When
Dobkin handed out "lesbian dollars" to bid on items from her "bag
of tricks," Yates was quick to bid "whatever you want; anything!"
for her desired item. Others jumped at the chance to bid on the vibrating pillow
to sit on. "We like vibrating stuff!" exclaimed the winners.
Storm
shared a poem about a fantasy she had of an old lady sitting in front of her on
the bus. She pictured her having sex with another woman half her age, and
described the old lady's hands as "hands that may have been inside her,
and very well may have been inside another woman."
Womyn's
Concerns and FMLA alleged misrepresentation of CuntFest to get funding and
approval may lead to serious and long-lasting consequences. Student officials at
Penn State have already asked for the notes and tapes recorded at the event in
order to amass evidence in the case.
As
Covener said about the lack of resources being diverted to questionable events
such as this one, "Many groups complain about the lack of cash for
scholarly activities such as attending professional conferences, meanwhile we
are spending thousands of dollars on 'pussy juice'?"
|